Drinking water has become a competitive sport.
People carry around enormous bottles with little lines telling them how much water they should have finished by 10 o’clock, noon, and 2 o’clock.
Fall behind and apparently you’re failing at hydration.
Whatever happened to just drinking when you’re thirsty?
For years we’ve been told to drink eight glasses of water every day. Some people insist on a gallon.
But where did those numbers come from?
In 2002, Dr. Heinz Valtin at Dartmouth went looking for the science behind the eight-glass rule. He couldn’t find convincing evidence that healthy adults needed to follow it.
And in 2024, researchers reviewed 18 clinical trials involving changes in water intake. They found some benefits for certain conditions, but surprisingly little evidence supporting the idea that everybody needs to drink more.
Here’s where things get interesting.
Peggy and I have spent years encouraging people to drink more water, especially when they complain about leg cramps. Sometimes we discover they’re barely drinking any.
But that doesn’t mean everybody needs more water.
There’s a big difference between giving your body what it needs and forcing down another quart because somebody on the internet told you to.
Your body needs water. Sometimes more than usual, especially when you’re sweating, working hard, or dealing with certain health problems. And thirst isn’t always a perfect guide.
But does a healthy person sitting at a desk really need to force down another quart because the clock says it’s time?
Somewhere along the way, we turned a basic human need into another thing to worry about.
I’m beginning to think we’ve managed to make even drinking water unnecessarily complicated.


Absolutely - drink more water and run to the loo more often. Maybe the benefit is in the increased step count?